“Prodigy Insurance has assisted us not only with our personal needs for insurance but also our business. Dave and his staff have always been very prompt answering questions, emails, phone calls, and making changes to our policies as we request. Whether it’s a new vehicle or changes to our general liability policy, it’s always handled promptly and efficiently. Their service is outstanding and you can really see they genuinely care about their customers. I couldn’t ask for a better group of people to handle our insurance needs.”

Kim H.

“We appreciate you saving us over $1,000.00 a year on our Home and Auto Insurance. We were with State Farm for Thirty-Five years and can’t remember the last time we had a decrease in premiums.”

Henry S.

“Prodigy Insurance has my highest recommendation. It’s so refreshing to work with a local firm that clearly values customer service and is always responsive in addressing the insurance needs for my family. Also, the annual Prodigy customer appreciation crawfish boil is on our calendar every year as a must event. Just an example of their commitment and the genuine appreciation to the customer. Thank you Prodigy!”

Dave F.

“We have been very happy with Prodigy Insurance. After many years with State Farm, we switched to Travelers at Jayce’s direction- coupled with our homeowners and cars, we are saving over $1200 per year!”

Doug and Susie R.

“Many insurance companies have automated phone service, for some this is fine, for some it’s not. Sometimes answers can be given through automation while some can’t. Dave has either been available or promptly returned my phone calls to answer any questions I’ve had. He lives in my community and has a vested reason to provide the best customer service he can, to those who reside here or nearby. In my experiences with his office, from the receptionist to Dave himself I’ve been met with professionalism and courtesy.Thanks Dave and congratulations on the move and better visibility to better serve our community.”

Buddy M.

“I would just like to state how pleased I am to have Prodigy Insurance group filling all my insurance needs. They are extremely pleasant to deal with and work very hard to find you the best rates. One of the best insurance carriers I’ve had the pleasure to work with. Just wanted to say THANK YOU Prodigy!”

Mark W.

“I just wanted to drop you guys a quick note to let you know how happy we are to have come to Prodigy Insurance Group. We had been with Farmers for the last 25+ years and always believed I was receiving not only the best discounts but the best service. I could not have been more wrong. You and your team could not have been nicer or more professional. Not only did I save more money than I could have imagined but after comparing policy to policy I have much better coverages with the homeowners, auto and umbrella policies you issued for us. Everyone there could not have been friendlier or more helpful. Thank you so much. I am now committed to Prodigy.”

Cynthia O.

“Dave at Prodigy Insurance in Porter is wonderful. We have several policies with them; cars, motorcycles, flood and home owners. My husband and I have only been with the group for few years but what peaceful years they have been. Dave has saved us time and money over the past years. He will review our policies with us each year to see if he can get us a better deal. This year Dave has really saved us a lot of time and money. He researched and found out that we had been paying about two and half times what we needed to be paying on insurance. It has been so nice and peaceful not having to worry about reviewing and researching our insurance needs. Dave has been great at doing all that for us. Words cannot state how much we appreciate Dave and all he has done for us, but here is a small try at it “thank you for all you have done, Dave.”

Kathy and Donald E.

“I wanted to tell you about my experience at Prodigy Insurance Group. I hate paying for insurance but it’s life and we all have to have it. My insurance kept going up and up, AND I have 2 teen drivers. I saw the signs at Prodigy while I was at work, so I dropped in and asked for a quote for my cars and home. Boy, was I surprised! They SAVED ME $2500.00 A YEAR!!! I was totally amazed! The customer service is out of this world. It’s hard to find anybody who cares if you do business with them, but the folks at Prodigy do care. I am in the business of serving customers too, and it’s always nice to find people who care about their customers. So a year later and my policy just renewed and I am still amazed again. I will continue to shop here and tell everybody I know about PRODIGY INSURANCE GROUP.”

Natalie C.

“I love the fact that Prodigy Insurance is local and the people are great to work with. Not only did I save $500 on my home insurance, but the transaction was smooth from start to finish. Best of all, I ended up with better coverage for less money!”

Paul B.

“You are the best!!!!!!!!!!
I’m so glad we switched over to your company. I have never been happier or treated so well by an insurance agent until I got with you!!! Everything you do for me and my family cannot be matched by anyone!!! All of you go out of your way to be helpful and make you feel like a person, not just a number or another policy. Some agents wouldn’t go out of their way to do the things I’ve asked of you. Ya’ll are NUMBER 1 in my book and I tell everyone I know!!!!”

Ken D.

“Thank you for helping us out with our home and auto insurance coverage. It was hard to believe you saved us money and increased coverage at the same time.”

Chris & Lisa

“Wow, Bryce and the team at Prodigy are the best in the business. I was amazed at their speed to action to address my needs. Prodigy will be my first call for all my insurance needs in the future.”

Mitch & Wendi

“Thanks so much for your help. It’s sad to think that I am possibly excited about a bill, but I feel as though I am getting great coverage, low deductibles, and it feels like I bought it on sale!”

Katharine K.

“I switched my Home, Auto and Umbrella insurance to Prodigy and saved $2,545 per year and got better coverage!! How can that happen? I don’t have the time to continually shop my insurance and now Prodigy does that for me every year.”

David & Liz

“Not only did I save money on my policy but I was able to get better coverage for both my Home and Auto.”

Happy customer

“As result of asking Prodigy Insurance Group for a quote, I found out I was dangerously underinsured. They worked very hard to come up with coverage for both my home and auto to bring me up to the required levels to avoid a huge risk with my belongings, my loved ones and my financial security. They provided this additional protection for me at very little additional cost.”

Happy customer

“My insurance rates have gone up over 20% in the last year. I appreciate the fact that Bryce took the time to understand how my family’s needs have changed over the past couple of years and made recommendations accordingly. I was able to change my coverage to better suit my needs of today and save money while doing so.”

Happy customer

“What sets Prodigy Insurance apart is their high level of customer service. It’s nice to know that if we have a question or problem, I can simply call Prodigy (Bryce Kotowych) and get help right away. They have responded quickly and have been flexible to our specific needs. Unlike so many insurance companies out there, Prodigy provides timely assistance and works closely with us to ensure we get the best service and value.”

Pete & Chantell C.